The American Question

What is the glue that holds a country together?

Following numerous subjects from December 2016, The American Question examines the insidious roots of American polarization and distrust, in a desperate search for a path forward.

Guided by an all-star lineup of experts, including Amy Chua (Day of Empire), Colin Woodard (American Nations), Yuval Levin (The Fractured Republic) and Yascha Mounk (The People vs. Democracy), The American Question reframes the heightened stakes of the 2024 election through revisiting the last 8 years of civic discord, revealing new revelations on how decades of decline dissolved public trust — presenting solutions to restore our democracy.

From director James Kicklighter (The Sound of Identity), The American Question is produced by Guy Seemann, p.g.a. and James Kicklighter, p.g.a., with executive producers S. Asher Gelman (Afterglow) and Marika Feuerstein. The director of photography is Jonathan Pope (Emmy® Award Nominee, The Social Dilemma) and film edited by Mohamed El Manasterly (Emmy® Award Winner, The Square), J.D. Sievertson ("Cosmos") and Carlos Puga (Emmy® Award Winner, “True Life"), with an original score from Nicolas Repetto, featuring original animation from Filmograph (Ghostbusters: Afterlife, Candyman, Promising Young Woman).

  • James Kicklighter
    Director
    The Sound of Identity, Angel of Anywhere
  • Guy Seemann
    Producer
  • James Kicklighter
    Producer
    The Sound of Identity, Angel of Anywhere
  • Lucy Copp
    Writer
    The Story of God with Morgan Freeman
  • James Kicklighter
    Writer
    The Sound of Identity, Desires of the Heart
  • Guy Seemann
    Writer
  • Jonathan Pope
    Director of Photography
    Emmy® Award Nominee, The Social Dilemma
  • Mohamed el Manasterly
    Editors
    Emmy® Award Winner, The Square
  • J.D. Sievertson, ACE
    Editors
    Emmy® Award Nominee, Cosmos: Possible Worlds
  • Amy Chua
    Key Cast
    John M. Duff Professor of Law, Yale University
  • Colin Woodard
    Key Cast
    Journalist, American Nations
  • Yascha Mounk
    Key Cast
    Journalist, The Atlantic
  • Isabel V. Sawhill
    Key Cast
    Senior Fellow, Brookings Institute
  • Carol Graham
    Key Cast
    Senior Fellow, Brookings Institute
  • Yuval Levin
    Key Cast
    Senior Fellow, American Enterprise Institute
  • Tania Israel
    Key Cast
    American Psychological Association and Author, Beyond Your Bubble
  • David Azzerad
    Key Cast
    Former Director, Heritage Foundation
  • Ange Hancock-Alfaro
    Key Cast
    Chair of Political Science, University of Southern California
  • Filmograph
    Animation and Graphics
    Candyman, Promising Young Woman, Aquaman
  • Project Type:
    Documentary, Feature
  • Genres:
    Political, America, American Values
  • Runtime:
    1 hour 30 minutes
  • Completion Date:
    May 1, 2023
  • Production Budget:
    200,000 USD
  • Country of Origin:
    United States
  • Country of Filming:
    Israel, United States
  • Language:
    English
  • Shooting Format:
    Digital
  • Aspect Ratio:
    2:35
  • Film Color:
    Color
  • First-time Filmmaker:
    No
  • Student Project:
    No
Distribution Information
  • United Talent Agency (Travis Tammero)
    Sales Agent
    Country: Worldwide
    Rights: All Rights
Director Biography - James Kicklighter

Director James Kicklighter spent the first eighteen years of his life in Bellville, Georgia, population 123. Since then, he has gone on to become an award-winning director and producer of narrative films, documentaries and advertising.

His work has been recognized by the world’s press, including The Hollywood Reporter, The Times of India, Film Courage and FilmInk Australia. Kicklighter has served as a panelist at the Oscar®-qualifying Hollyshorts Film Festival, taught filmmaking courses on Stage32.com, and his interview series with the popular YouTube channel Film Courage has over 250,000 views.

In June 2021, Shout! Studios released The Sound of Identity, premiering on STARZ and now streaming on Prime Video, rated 91% fresh on Rotten Tomatoes. Also avaliable on-demand in the United States and Canada on AppleTV, Google Play, Vudu, and other platforms, in the spotlight of global media coverage, Lucia Lucas, the first transgender woman to perform as Don Giovanni in a professional opera, makes her historic debut in one of the reddest states in America.

From director James Kicklighter, The Sound of Identity is produced by Emmy Award-winning producers Russ Kirkpatrick & Andy Kinslow and is executive produced by Golden Globe®-winner and Academy Award®-nominated Josh Bachove (Minari, The Little Hours), with Jonathan Pope (Emmy® Award Nominee, The Social Dilemma) on as Director of Photography.

He resides in Los Angeles, California with his husband, Xintong, and dog, Oscar, and still can't believe he gets to work across the country and around the globe.

Add Director Biography
Director Statement

The American Question is a decisive snapshot of American values and how they impact the way our society, and in turn the world, operates. For decades, America’s most important export has been values, and if our values are in disarray, so the global culture will follow.

With the rise of globalization, we have slowly but surely divided ourselves into international “city-nations” that have little in common with places only an hour outside of the metropolitan/cosmopolitan regions. To be clear, places like New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago have more in common with London, Sydney and Shanghai than areas only an hour outside of their jurisdiction. This is something I know acutely on a personal level.

According to The New York Times, I grew up in one of the poorest counties in America, both economically and educationally. In my Title I public school education, 90% of students were on free or reduced lunch. Very few in my graduating class were afforded the opportunity to graduate from college, even less living outside of the state of Georgia. Most reside within a fifty-mile radius of where we grew up. Why is this so?

Where I was raised, no one has rich uncles or family members who can provide them with economic mobility. The job market provides you with limited options: working in the prison system, school system, agriculture, or very limited options within the private sector.

Raised by a single mother after my father’s unexpected passing, I spent my teenage years creating high school graduation videos, documentaries, and children’s audiobooks in order to save money to start making my own projects. Through that work, I got into film festivals, saved money to attend them and eventually, was able to make my way to Los Angeles where I have since directed other documentaries, narrative films, music videos and ad campaigns.

I am an exception, not the rule, and I recognize that every time I am home and meet my childhood friends who struggle to put food on the table — they gaze at my life on Instagram, taking pictures with Miley Cyrus, as I traverse the globe working in places they could never see.

That is why I have joined this team to tell this story, because my entire worldview is framed by this insider/outsider perspective, privy to a world that was impossible to access as a child raised in a town of 123 citizens. How can someone who grew up in Los Angeles or New York, from which many people in the entertainment industry hail, begin to understand the struggles of my friends and family?

Because of this insider/outsider perspective, I understand the other half of the coin that people where I grew up cannot see. They don’t realize that the $50,000 house they can buy would cost a million in my neighborhood. They don’t have to compete with an international marketplace in a cosmopolitan city. In many respects, they also don’t have to live in a world with diverse cultures and faith backgrounds. Thus, how can we begin to expect one side to understand the other when no one seems to be able to speak for both sides?

Directorially, I have a voice and deeply rooted passion that can speak to bridging that gap. Truthfully, both Americas have similar goals in pursuit of what our culture has determined as the American Dream. We all want a house, a car and to create a life that is better than our parents. How we arrive there, however, is quite different.

If you live in an area where economic and educational opportunities are abundant, then we have access to utilize those resources. With them, we become comfortable in our lives. As those things are satisfied, we then begin to grow the pyramid described in Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs.

Yet if you live in an area where none of these opportunities are available, then you cannot put food on the table, and thus, why should you care about social, environmental or other issues that aren’t tangible to your basic well-being?

The American Question attempts to bridge that gap through showcasing shared American values, as defined by the Constitution, and how those values connect to current events, such as globalization, immigration and communal decay. We do it through cities in every sector of the country, rural, suburban and urban, that serve as microcosms for these broader societal shifts, places that represent and are connective to all parts of America.

Through exploring these vast topics with intellectual openness and curiosity, we eschew our preconceived notions, and indeed life experiences, by putting ourselves in the shoes of the subject to understand how they arrived at their conclusion.

We neither demonize nor praise different parts of America, permitting the viewer to understand their issues, identify the common values that our culture collectively feels is different, and provide a cautionary tale framed by cultures past, if ours cannot find a way to come together.

These goals might sound lofty, and they are. But if we can start a conversation, then people can remove their own personal politics from the equation to understand each other as Americans once again.